Jump to content

Primary: Sky Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Secondary: Sky Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Pattern: Blank Waves Squares Notes Sharp Wood Rockface Leather Honey Vertical Triangles
* * * * * (4.78 - 18votes)

Tokyo Ghoul: Redrawn


Alt Names:
Author: Ishida Sui
Artist: Ishida Sui
Genres: Action ActionAward Winning Award WinningDrama DramaHorror HorrorMartial Arts Martial ArtsMystery MysteryPsychological PsychologicalSeinen SeinenSupernatural SupernaturalTragedy Tragedy
Type: Manga (Japanese)
Status: Complete
Description: A redrawn variant of Chapter 1: Tragedy.
Go to Tokyo Ghoul: Redrawn Forums! | Scroll Down to Comments
The following content is intended for mature audiences and may contain sexual themes, gore, violence and/or strong language. Discretion is advised.


Latest Forum Posts

Topic Started By Stats Last Post Info
No topics has been found for this comic.

x

Register now for full access! You'll be able to follow (bookmark) your favorites, get updates on new releases, and more! It's completely free and only takes a minute.



19 Comments

I like the re-contextualisation of ghouls. It was kinda inconsistent in the original how Kaneki and Hide didn't know how ghouls look exactly like humans given how long ghouls were around.

idk if its just me but i prefer the original art and rize looked fine back then. the new art looks way to digital and you can tell its done by tablet. i like his old art 

Yeah. I'm surprised they messed with the panels and dialog. I went back and re-read the original and I prefer it.

idk if its just me but i prefer the original art and rize looked fine back then. the new art looks way to digital and you can tell its done by tablet. i like his old art 

Ishida has always worked with a tablet, though, this isn't new. 

idk if its just me but i prefer the original art and rize looked fine back then. the new art looks way to digital and you can tell its done by tablet. i like his old art 

'I just thought it would be super neat if we could talk to each other about books, that's all~"

 

Sweet innocent Kaneki. Untainted by the ghoul world lol.

For those of you complaining about the quality of TG:Re's art, here's something to keep in mind if you're reading your chapters from a certain other team that can be abbreviated as MS.

 

One of MS's focuses is on being fast. And they are fast! Amazingly fast! And the quality they deliver is pretty great given how fast they are! But because they need to be fast, they not only need to go through the various scanlating steps as quickly as possible, they need to use the first set of raws they can get. That means using magazine raws, and while I can't comment on the exact quality of MS's raws, magazine scans are generally kind of bad even on a good day. Here's an idea of the kind of quality we're talking about.

 

You can imagine how details can be lost cleaning/redrawing such raws, especially if you're trying to go fast. Normally if you want better quality art, you'd need to wait for the collected volumes, and that happens several months after the magazine release. Definitely not an option if you're trying to go fast! But with TG:Re, there is a third option.

 

Young Jump releases several of its series online, and TG:Re is one of them! As you can see, it's two chapters behind MS, but the quality is much better. In fact, I vaguely remember reading somewhere that this is basically the digital files that Ishida drew, put up on the internet for people to see (pls correct me if im wrong). Doesn't get much better than that!

 

So if there's a scene in the manga that seems particularly muddled and you don't mind waiting, you can always check out the high quality raws for art details. Or if you want english in your manga, you can always wait for someone to scanlate the hq version. Right here on batoto in fact! Releases by crossbreed scans use the hq raws, and their translation quality is generally better (again, see going fast above).

 

Of course, if you're complaining about the art in the high quality raws, then I can't help you :P

 

EDIT: And because a picture is worth a thousand words, a side by side comparison, not against MS scans, but against a fan scanlation using less than optimal raws. You get the point.

He should focus on Re. The fight scenes are such crap, do they really think it looks good? Or are they going for "its so edgy cuz you dont know wtf is going on." Either way, something needs to be done....

>"Lives the same way humans do"

>Turns into ghoul

>Proceeds to pretty much kill EVERYTHING

Best.Day.Ever. 

The chapter that started it all being redrawn by the masterful Ishida-sensei is the best thing ever. 

Sometime's I wonder if Ishida even sleep's ...

 

 

I don't really think Tokyo Ghoul need's a redrawn version, but I would love to have one for Tokyo Ghoul:re not that I hate the art there but sometime's the fight's look kinda melted x'D

I know. Really, sometimes the drawings of Re seem like made without time. Other times I can't actually understand what the hell is happening or who is actually fighting.

Sometime's I wonder if Ishida even sleep's ...

 

 

I don't really think Tokyo Ghoul need's a redrawn version, but I would love to have one for Tokyo Ghoul:re not that I hate the art there but sometime's the fight's look kinda melted x'D

Looool, I love the Afterword and the cover and the double color page...and well the whole series xD

Is this really happening!? or he just redraw only the first chapter...?

 

1st chapter only as a one-off promo

 

doesnt really make fiscal sense to redraw the whole series

Thank you Ishida-sensei for your gracious work!! I'm definitely all excitement for this redrawn version!!! <3<3<3

If only he could paint with a different color each fighter in the middle of the brawl I could notice who is who (lol)

Thank you Ishida-sensei for your gracious work!! I'm definitely all excitement for this redrawn version!!! <3<3<3

Is this really happening!? or he just redraw only the first chapter...?

(Inhales the tragedy)

God the art is just gorgeous.

Certainly an improvement but I would have never called the old chapter ugly or Rize a pig. Eating as well as she did just gave her some nice curves. 


Search Comics